| Games | Won | Drew | Lost | Scored | Conceded |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 18 | 3 | 1 | 14 | 21 | 59 |
| F.A. Challenge Cup | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat 16/08/14 | Winsford United | 0-1 | Athersley Recreation | HT: 0-0 |
| Lee Bennett (56) | Att: 107 | |||
| Sat 15/08/15 | Alsager Town | 1-0 | Athersley Recreation | HT: 0-0 |
| Jordan Southwell (70) | Att: 110 | |||
| Sat 05/08/17 | Athersley Recreation | 0-5 | West Didsbury & Chorlton | HT: 0-2 |
| Kevin McGrath (13) Tom Bailey (19) Nic Evangelinos (48) Joe Shaw (58) Tom Bailey (79) | Att: 113 | |||
| Sat 10/08/19 | Athersley Recreation | 0-4 | Padiham | HT: 0-2 |
| James Dean (29) Danny Morton (39) Jay Hill (51) James Dean (78) | Att: 101 | |||
| Tue 01/09/20 | Athersley Recreation | 1-4 | Charnock Richard | HT: 1-1 |
| James Purcell (35) | Nathan Nickeas (28) Nathan Nickeas (62) Lewis Haydock (71) Carl Grimshaw (90p) | Att: 284 | ||
| Sat 07/08/21 | Athersley Recreation | 1-4 | Campion | HT: 0-2 |
| Dane Shaw (78) | Nicky Boshell (29) Jason Carney (36) Own Goal (55) Thomas Ramsden (90) | Att: 101 |
| F.A. Carlsberg Vase | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat 21/09/13 | Athersley Recreation | 5-0 | Northwich Flixton Villa | HT: 4-0 |
| Kieron Scargill (3) Jason Bentley (5) Lee Bennett (13) Joe Thornton (40) Joe Thornton (71) |
Att: 128 | |||
| Sat 19/10/13 | Chadderton | 2-3 | Athersley Recreation | HT: 1-2 |
| Michael Cheetham (3) Matthew Russell (69) |
Jeff Thornton (18) Lee Bennett (30) Jeff Thornton (57) | Att: 70 | ||
| Sat 04/10/14 | Athersley Recreation | 1-4 | Runcorn Town | HT: 0-2 |
| Daniel Joynes (50) | Jack Webb (18) Paul Shanley (27) Daniel Toone (74) Daniel Toone (89p) | Att: 171 | ||
| Sat 31/10/15 | Athersley Recreation | 1-5 | Colne | HT: 1-2 |
| Tom Harban (17) | Kenny Taylor (25) Ben Hoskin (28) Danny Boyle (72) Adam Stockdale (79) Jason Hart (80) | Att: 90 | ||
| Sat 10/09/16 | Ashton Athletic | 2-0 | Athersley Recreation | HT: 2-0 |
| Joel Brownhill (16) Paul Watson (37) |
Att: 67 | |||
| Sun 10/09/17 | AFC Liverpool | 3-2 | Athersley Recreation | HT: 2-1 |
| Kevin Edgar (39) Joseph Whittington (43) Adam Weston (60p) |
Jamie Moxon (23) Kyle Wadsworth (65) | Att: 118 | ||
| Sat 01/09/18 | Sandbach United | 5-1 | Athersley Recreation | HT: 0-0 |
| Kieran Garner-Knapper (64) James Kirby (77) Kieran Garner-Knapper (80) James Kirby (86) Ryan Allcock (90+1) |
Ryan White (71) | Att: 104 | ||
| Sat 31/08/19 | Warrington Rylands 1906 | 6-0 | Athersley Recreation | HT: 5-0 |
| Callum Lees (1) Jay White (24) Jay White (36) Freddie Potter (37) Jay White (40) Feddie Potter (60) |
Att: 97 | |||
| Sat 19/09/20 | Cheadle Town | 1-1 | Athersley Recreation | HT: 0-0 |
| Patrick Davin (88p) | Innocent Huly (85) | Att: 112 | ||
| (Cheadle Town won 4-3 on penalties) | ||||
| Sat 11/09/21 | Athersley Recreation | 1-5 | Chadderton | HT: 1-1 |
| Charlie Clegg (42) | Ethan Sutcliffe (10) Ethan Sutcliffe (50) Jordan Schofield (53) Harry Dean (75) Joseph Richards (80) | Att: 121 | ||
| Sat 23/09/23 | Burscough | 3-0 | Athersley Recreation | HT: 2-0 |
| Tom Lawless (20) Charles Ball (30) Tom Lawless (63) |
Att: 100 | |||
| Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat 25/11/23 | Shelley | 5-3 | Athersley Recreation | HT: 2-2 |
| Antony Leech (25) Akram Lasalire (36) George Whittaker (49) Akram Lasalire (60) Akram Lasalire (89) |
Louis Wardle (10) Connor Peace (17) Connor Peace (80) | Att: 61 |
