| 03/08/19 | Pilkington 0-3 Cleator Moor |
| 07/08/19 | AFC Liverpool 3-3 Pilkington |
| 10/08/19 | Pilkington 1-2 Chadderton |
| 26/08/19 | Pilkington 0-2 Ashton Town *
Yellow Card |
| 31/08/19 | Pilkington 2-2 Atherton LR |
| 07/09/19 | Pilkington 3-2 Emley AFC |
| 14/09/19 | Lower Breck 4-3 Pilkington |
| 21/09/19 | Pilkington 1-2 AFC Blackpool |
| 28/09/19 | Steeton 2-0 Pilkington |
| 02/10/19 | Garstang 0-8 Pilkington
1 goal , Yellow Card |
| 05/10/19 | Chadderton 0-1 Pilkington |
| 12/10/19 | Atherton LR 0-2 Pilkington |
| 19/10/19 | Pilkington 1-3 Steeton |
| 24/10/19 | Lower Breck 1-2 Pilkington |
| 26/10/19 | Pilkington 1-5 Golcar United |
| 30/10/19 | AFC Darwen 1-5 Pilkington |
| 02/11/19 | Pilkington 5-1 Daisy Hill
1 goal |
| 13/11/19 | Pilkington 3-2 Holker OB |
| 26/11/19 | Marine 2-3 Pilkington |
| 30/11/19 | Daisy Hill 3-1 Pilkington |
| 14/12/19 | Lower Breck 3-0 Pilkington |
| 26/12/19 | Pilkington 3-2 St Helens Town *
Yellow Card |
| 28/12/19 | Ashton Town 3-2 Pilkington |
| 04/01/20 | Pilkington 3-1 Atherton LR |
| 08/01/20 | Pilkington 2-1 Garstang
Yellow Card |
| 11/01/20 | Nelson 2-3 Pilkington |
| 18/01/20 | Shelley 4-1 Pilkington
Sin Bin |
| 22/01/20 | Southport 4-1 Pilkington |
| 01/02/20 | Pilkington 4-1 Bacup Borough
Yellow Card |
| 08/02/20 | AFC Blackpool 4-1 Pilkington |
| 15/02/20 | Pilkington 2-0 Steeton |
| 07/03/20 | Holker OB 2-0 Pilkington
Sin Bin |
| 14/03/20 | Pilkington 3-2 Nelson |
