| 21/09/19 | New Mills 1-1 Alsager Town *
Yellow Card |
| 24/09/19 | New Mills 3-3 West Didsbury *
1 goal , Sin Bin |
| 28/09/19 | Wythenshawe Am 0-2 New Mills |
| 01/10/19 | Wythenshawe Town 4-0 New Mills |
| 09/10/19 | Graham Street 0-2 New Mills
Yellow Card |
| 19/10/19 | West Didsbury 3-1 New Mills
Yellow Card |
| 22/10/19 | New Mills 1-3 Sandbach
Yellow Card |
| 02/11/19 | New Mills 4-4 Cammell Laird
Yellow Card |
| 05/11/19 | 1-2 New Mills |
| 16/11/19 | Alsager Town 0-2 New Mills
Yellow Card , MoM |
| 19/11/19 | Ellesmere Rngrs 2-0 New Mills |
| 23/11/19 | New Mills 1-3 Vauxhall Mtrs |
| 26/11/19 | New Mills 6-1 Abbey Hulton
Yellow Card |
| 30/11/19 | Cheadle Heath 2-0 New Mills
Yellow Card |
| 18/12/19 | New Mills 2-1 Derby County
Yellow Card |
| 11/01/20 | New Mills 1-2 Cheadle Town
Yellow Card |
| 18/01/20 | New Mills 2-4 Wythenshawe Town
Yellow Card |
| 25/01/20 | Cammell Laird 4-5 New Mills
2 goals |
| 01/02/20 | Abbey Hulton 2-6 New Mills
1 goal |
| 08/02/20 | New Mills 1-1 Maine Road
Yellow Card |
| 03/03/20 | Belper Town 2-1 New Mills
1 goal , Yellow Card |
| 07/03/20 | Eccleshall 1-2 New Mills
2 goals , Yellow Card |
