| Date | Match |
|---|---|
| 29/07/23 | Garstang 3-5 Darwen FC |
| 02/08/23 | Garstang 2-3 Atherton LR |
| 05/08/23 | South Liverpool 3-0 Garstang |
| 12/08/23 | FC St Helens 2-0 Garstang |
| 26/08/23 | Carlisle City 5-3 Garstang |
| 28/08/23 | Garstang 6-2 Ashton Athletic  |
| 02/09/23 | Runcorn Town 2-2 Garstang |
| 16/09/23 | Garstang 2-0 Shelley * |
| 23/09/23 | Darwen FC 2-2 Garstang * |
| 27/09/23 | Longridge Town 2-2 Garstang |
| 30/09/23 | Route One Rovers 6-2 Garstang |
| 07/10/23 | Garstang 3-4 FC St Helens  |
| 10/10/23 | Nelson 2-2 Garstang |
| 14/10/23 | Bacup Borough 4-1 Garstang |
| 21/10/23 | Garstang 2-2 Nelson |
| 05/12/23 | Longridge Town 2-1 Garstang * |
| 26/12/23 | Holker OB 2-3 Garstang |
| 06/01/24 | Nelson 4-1 Garstang |
| 07/02/24 | Garstang 1-4 Route One Rovers * |
| 17/02/24 | Ilkley Town 4-2 Garstang * |
| 02/03/24 | Garstang 3-2 Ashton Town  |
| 23/03/24 | Ashton Athletic 5-1 Garstang |
| 30/03/24 | Garstang 2-4 Steeton |
| 06/04/24 | Atherton LR 3-1 Garstang |
| 13/04/24 | Daisy Hill 1-2 Garstang |
| 17/04/24 | Garstang 0-6 AFC Blackpool |
* Indicates appearance as a substitute
| Comp | Team | App |
|---|---|---|
| The Isuzu FA Vase | Garstang | 1 |
| The Macron Cup | Garstang | 1 |
| The Edward Case Cup | Garstang | 1 |
| Lancashire Challenge Trophy | Garstang | 1 |
| First Division North | Garstang | 22 |
| Comp | YC | SB | RC |
|---|---|---|---|
| First Division North | 2 | 0 | 1 |
